2025
Other
Restricted
Manuale per la compilazione del registro delle attività di trattamento del titolare e del responsabile
Amenta Valentina, Deluca Rosaria, Glielmi Alessia, Ianigro Massimo, Micolitti Olga, Niccoli Daniela, Olivieri Angelo, Ponzio Sabina, Pugliese Maria Teresa, Ravazzi Laura, Rendine Sara Sandy, Volpini Federico.
Il Gruppo di lavoro di supporto al DG sulle problematiche in materia di protezione dei dati personali ha creato un’applicazione web che consente di compilare e aggiornare il Registro dei Trattamenti direttamente online in formato elettronico. Scopo del presente documento è quello di fornire una guida pratica sulla compilazione e aggiornamento del Registro dei Trattamenti elettronico del Titolare e del Responsabile. Per ulteriori approfondimenti, anche in merito al significato di alcune definizioni e in generale ai riferimenti normativi, si rinvia alle Linee guida sull'argomento.
Amenta Valentina, Deluca Rosaria, Glielmi Alessia, Ianigro Massimo, Micolitti Olga, Niccoli Daniela, Olivieri Angelo, Ponzio Sabina, Pugliese Maria Teresa, Ravazzi Laura, Rendine Sara Sandy, Volpini Federico.
Il Gruppo di lavoro di supporto al DG sulle problematiche in materia di protezione dei dati personali ha creato un’applicazione web che consente di compilare e aggiornare il Registro dei Trattamenti direttamente online in formato elettronico. Scopo del presente documento è quello di fornire una guida pratica sulla compilazione e aggiornamento del Registro dei Trattamenti elettronico del Titolare e del Responsabile. Per ulteriori approfondimenti, anche in merito al significato di alcune definizioni e in generale ai riferimenti normativi, si rinvia alle Linee guida sull'argomento.
2025
Other
Restricted
Linee Guida per la compilazione del registro delle attività di trattamento dei titolari e dei responsabili
Amenta Valentina, Deluca Rosaria, Glielmi Alessia, Ianigro Massimo, Micolitti Olga, Niccoli Daniela, Olivieri Angelo, Ponzio Sabina, Pugliese Maria Teresa, Ravazzi Laura, Rendine Sara Sandy, Volpini Federico.
Le presenti linee guida costituiscono uno mero strumento di supporto e hanno lo scopo di facilitare la compilazione e l’aggiornamento del Registro delle attività di trattamento del Titolare e del Responsabile utilizzando l’apposita applicazione web.
Amenta Valentina, Deluca Rosaria, Glielmi Alessia, Ianigro Massimo, Micolitti Olga, Niccoli Daniela, Olivieri Angelo, Ponzio Sabina, Pugliese Maria Teresa, Ravazzi Laura, Rendine Sara Sandy, Volpini Federico.
Le presenti linee guida costituiscono uno mero strumento di supporto e hanno lo scopo di facilitare la compilazione e l’aggiornamento del Registro delle attività di trattamento del Titolare e del Responsabile utilizzando l’apposita applicazione web.
2023
Conference article
Open Access
Trustworthy AI at KDD Lab
Giannotti F, Guidotti R, Monreale A, Pappalardo L, Pedreschi D, Pellungrini R, Pratesi F, Rinzivillo S, Ruggieri S, Setzu M, Deluca R
This document summarizes the activities regarding the development of Responsible AI (Responsible Artificial Intelligence) conducted by the Knowledge Discovery and Data mining group (KDD-Lab), a joint research group of the Institute of Information Science and Technologies "Alessandro Faedo" (ISTI) of the National Research Council of Italy (CNR), the Department of Computer Science of the University of Pisa, and the Scuola Normale Superiore of Pisa.Source: CEUR WORKSHOP PROCEEDINGS, pp. 388-393. Pisa, Italy, 29-30/05/2023
Project(s): SoBigData-PlusPlus
Giannotti F, Guidotti R, Monreale A, Pappalardo L, Pedreschi D, Pellungrini R, Pratesi F, Rinzivillo S, Ruggieri S, Setzu M, Deluca R
This document summarizes the activities regarding the development of Responsible AI (Responsible Artificial Intelligence) conducted by the Knowledge Discovery and Data mining group (KDD-Lab), a joint research group of the Institute of Information Science and Technologies "Alessandro Faedo" (ISTI) of the National Research Council of Italy (CNR), the Department of Computer Science of the University of Pisa, and the Scuola Normale Superiore of Pisa.Source: CEUR WORKSHOP PROCEEDINGS, pp. 388-393. Pisa, Italy, 29-30/05/2023
Project(s): SoBigData-PlusPlus
See at:
ceur-ws.org 
| CNR IRIS | ISTI Repository | CNR IRIS 
2022
Other
Restricted
GDPR: breve panoramica per un'applicazione consapevole. Il Report è corredato da moduli e formulari.
Amenta V, Deluca R
Il documento contiene una descrizione interpretativa delle principali disposizioni contenute nel Regolamento (eu) 2016/679 al fine di supportare il personale in merito alle attività di trattamento dati personali. Il documento è corredato da moduli e formulari.DOI: 10.32079/isti-tr-2022/002
Metrics:
Amenta V, Deluca R
Il documento contiene una descrizione interpretativa delle principali disposizioni contenute nel Regolamento (eu) 2016/679 al fine di supportare il personale in merito alle attività di trattamento dati personali. Il documento è corredato da moduli e formulari.DOI: 10.32079/isti-tr-2022/002
Metrics:
2022
Other
Open Access
Un modello di designazione dell'amministratore di sistema realizzato per il Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche in applicazione del Regolamento (UE) 2016/679 sulla protezione dei dati personali
Amenta V, Deluca R, Fullone A, Glielmi A, Ippoliti M, Micolitti O, Niccoli D
Predisposizione di un modello esemplificativo per la designazione della figura di amministratore di sistema, modulabile sulle base delle effettive specificità delle strutture CNR.DOI: 10.32079/isti-tr-2022/019
Metrics:
Amenta V, Deluca R, Fullone A, Glielmi A, Ippoliti M, Micolitti O, Niccoli D
Predisposizione di un modello esemplificativo per la designazione della figura di amministratore di sistema, modulabile sulle base delle effettive specificità delle strutture CNR.DOI: 10.32079/isti-tr-2022/019
Metrics:
See at:
CNR IRIS | ISTI Repository | CNR IRIS
2021
Other
Restricted
NAUTILOS - H - Requirement No. 1
Pieri G, Deluca R, Chatzinikolaou E
The procedures and criteria that will be used to identify/recruit research participants, as well as the informed consent procedures that will be implemented for the participation of humans external to NAUTILOS to the project activities and in regard to their data processing are presented in this document. Templates of the informed consent/assent forms and information sheets covering the voluntary participation and data protection issues, in the English version are provided.Project(s): NAUTILOS
Pieri G, Deluca R, Chatzinikolaou E
The procedures and criteria that will be used to identify/recruit research participants, as well as the informed consent procedures that will be implemented for the participation of humans external to NAUTILOS to the project activities and in regard to their data processing are presented in this document. Templates of the informed consent/assent forms and information sheets covering the voluntary participation and data protection issues, in the English version are provided.Project(s): NAUTILOS
2021
Other
Restricted
NAUTILOS - POPD - Requirement No. 2
Pieri G, Gianvincenzo A, Novellino A, Deluca R
This document is intended to provide recommendation on the procedures of the Information Systems and is inspired by the principles of correctness and diligence and is adopted in compliance with the provisions contained in the Privacy code and in the General Data Protection Regulation of the European Union.Project(s): NAUTILOS
Pieri G, Gianvincenzo A, Novellino A, Deluca R
This document is intended to provide recommendation on the procedures of the Information Systems and is inspired by the principles of correctness and diligence and is adopted in compliance with the provisions contained in the Privacy code and in the General Data Protection Regulation of the European Union.Project(s): NAUTILOS
2021
Other
Restricted
Ti Assisto - Sistema Informativo
Martinelli M, Deluca R, Moroni D
Il sistema informativo, le piattaforme pregresse, privacy, requisiti
Martinelli M, Deluca R, Moroni D
Il sistema informativo, le piattaforme pregresse, privacy, requisiti
2021
Other
Restricted
Building management system e privacy all'Area della Ricerca CNR di Pisa: "La casa del Registro. it"
Deluca R, Zanini A
Il lavoro descrive il modello di relazione tra sicurezza e privacy predisposto per fronteggiare le problematiche riguardanti l'utilizzo della tecnologia "Building Management System" implementata per la realizzazione della "Casa del Registro .it" (IIT-CNR), allo scopo di avere un edificio smart.
Deluca R, Zanini A
Il lavoro descrive il modello di relazione tra sicurezza e privacy predisposto per fronteggiare le problematiche riguardanti l'utilizzo della tecnologia "Building Management System" implementata per la realizzazione della "Casa del Registro .it" (IIT-CNR), allo scopo di avere un edificio smart.
2021
Other
Open Access
Il trattamento dei dati personali da parte dei soggetti autorizzati al trattamento nel Consiglio Nazionale delle Ricerche: istruzioni per il trattamento in applicazione del Regolamento UE 2016/679 sulla protezione dei dati personali declinate per l'Unità Affari Legali e Albo Avvocati.
Deluca R, Amenta V, Ippoliti M, Fullone A, Glielmi A, Niccoli D
Predisposizione di un modello esemplificativo contenente alcune ipotesi di misure tecniche e organizzative, avente la funzione di intercettare le plurime richieste delle strutture dell'Ente circa la necessità di poter disporre di una strumentazione di base, ma al tempo stesso modulabile sulla base delle effettive specificità delle stesse, cosi da metterle a disposizione delle strutture del C.N.R. (Amministrazione centrale e Rete scientifica).DOI: 10.32079/isti-tr-2021/018
Metrics:
Deluca R, Amenta V, Ippoliti M, Fullone A, Glielmi A, Niccoli D
Predisposizione di un modello esemplificativo contenente alcune ipotesi di misure tecniche e organizzative, avente la funzione di intercettare le plurime richieste delle strutture dell'Ente circa la necessità di poter disporre di una strumentazione di base, ma al tempo stesso modulabile sulla base delle effettive specificità delle stesse, cosi da metterle a disposizione delle strutture del C.N.R. (Amministrazione centrale e Rete scientifica).DOI: 10.32079/isti-tr-2021/018
Metrics:
See at:
CNR IRIS | ISTI Repository | CNR IRIS
2020
Other
Restricted
Linee guda sulle procedure di gestione della violazione dei dati personali (data breach)
Amenta V, Deluca R
Le presenti Linee guida sono state elaborate al fine di individuare una metodologia di gestione del data breach, ai sensi degli artt. 33 e 34 del Reg. EU 2016/679, da applicare in maniera coordinata all'Istituto di Informatica e Telematica (IIT-CNR) e all'Istituto di Scienza e Tecnologie dell'Informazione A. Faedo (ISTI-CNR)
Amenta V, Deluca R
Le presenti Linee guida sono state elaborate al fine di individuare una metodologia di gestione del data breach, ai sensi degli artt. 33 e 34 del Reg. EU 2016/679, da applicare in maniera coordinata all'Istituto di Informatica e Telematica (IIT-CNR) e all'Istituto di Scienza e Tecnologie dell'Informazione A. Faedo (ISTI-CNR)
See at:
CNR IRIS | CNR IRIS | www.isti.cnr.it
2020
Software
Restricted
Prototipo per l'integrazione della Privacy nella piattaforma del CNR "PDGP GEPRO"
Amenta V, Deluca R, Volpini F
Realizzazione di un prototipo per la compilazione guidata del Registro del Trattamento dati secondo le procedure indicate dall'art. 30 del GDPR.
Amenta V, Deluca R, Volpini F
Realizzazione di un prototipo per la compilazione guidata del Registro del Trattamento dati secondo le procedure indicate dall'art. 30 del GDPR.
See at:
CNR IRIS | CNR IRIS | ut6.isti.cnr.it
2020
Other
Restricted
Regolamento utilizzo dei sistemi informatici, rete telematica e sicurezza Istituto di Scienza e Tecnologie dell'informazione "A. Faedo" - Versione novembre 2020
Amendola T, Deluca R, Diciotti R, Fantini E, Piccioli T Volpini F
Internal regulation aimed at preventing unconscious behavior from triggering problems or threats to security in the processing of personal data.DOI: 10.32079/isti-tr-2020/031
Metrics:
Amendola T, Deluca R, Diciotti R, Fantini E, Piccioli T Volpini F
Internal regulation aimed at preventing unconscious behavior from triggering problems or threats to security in the processing of personal data.DOI: 10.32079/isti-tr-2020/031
Metrics:
2019
Other
Restricted
Linee guida sulla valutazione d'impatto (DPIA - Data Protection Impact Assessment)
Deluca R, Diciotti R, Fantini E, Piccioli T
Linee Guida sulla valutazione d'impatto ai sensi dell'art. 35 del Regolamento Europeo in materia di protezione dei dati personali (GDPR EU 2016/679).
Deluca R, Diciotti R, Fantini E, Piccioli T
Linee Guida sulla valutazione d'impatto ai sensi dell'art. 35 del Regolamento Europeo in materia di protezione dei dati personali (GDPR EU 2016/679).
See at:
CNR IRIS | CNR IRIS | www.isti.cnr.it
2019
Contribution to conference
Open Access
Privacy e ricerca scientifica: un connubio tra cognizione e metodo
Deluca R, Amenta V
Breve descrizione degli adempimenti privacy per chi svolge attività di ricerca
Deluca R, Amenta V
Breve descrizione degli adempimenti privacy per chi svolge attività di ricerca
See at:
CNR IRIS | ISTI Repository | CNR IRIS
2018
Other
Metadata Only Access
SteP News: Sicurezza, tutela e privacy
Deluca R, Volpini F, Amenta V
Il sito nasce allo scopo di sensibilizzare e far accrescere la consapevolezza dell'importanza della protezione dei dati personali, e di diffondere la cultura della sicurezza informatica per qualunque attività che comporti l'uso di sistemi informatici e/o telematici. In particolare sono approfonditi gli aspetti riguardanti il Regolamento in materia di protezione dei dati (General Data Protection Regulation) GDPR EU 2016/679, rischi e minacce che incombono sui dati, misure di sicurezza.
Deluca R, Volpini F, Amenta V
Il sito nasce allo scopo di sensibilizzare e far accrescere la consapevolezza dell'importanza della protezione dei dati personali, e di diffondere la cultura della sicurezza informatica per qualunque attività che comporti l'uso di sistemi informatici e/o telematici. In particolare sono approfonditi gli aspetti riguardanti il Regolamento in materia di protezione dei dati (General Data Protection Regulation) GDPR EU 2016/679, rischi e minacce che incombono sui dati, misure di sicurezza.
See at:
CNR IRIS | stepnews.isti.cnr.it
2018
Other
Restricted
Regolamento utilizzo dei sistemi informatici, rete telematica e sicurezza Istituto di Scienza e Tecnologie dell'informazione "A. Faedo"
Deluca R, Diciotti R, Fantini E, Gennai F, Piccioli T
Regolamento interno diretto ad evitare che comportamenti inconsapevoli possano innescare problemi o minacce alla sicurezza nel trattamento dei dati personali.
Deluca R, Diciotti R, Fantini E, Gennai F, Piccioli T
Regolamento interno diretto ad evitare che comportamenti inconsapevoli possano innescare problemi o minacce alla sicurezza nel trattamento dei dati personali.
See at:
CNR IRIS | CNR IRIS | regolamento.isti.cnr.it
2018
Journal article
Open Access
Grey Literature and Research Assessment Exercises: From the Current Criteria to the Open Science models
Giannini S, Deluca R, Molino A, Biagioni S
In the recent years the application of strategies, procedures and tools to evaluate the research have become subject of interest and their application is currently matter of discussion. The assessment exercises are regulated at national level and are carried out in different European countries such as France, United Kingdom and The Netherlands. In Italy the first research assessment exercise has been legislated in 2003 and entrusted to a specific Committee named Comitato di Indirizzo per la Valutazione della Ricerca (CIVR)1. Three years later the CIVR and other committees have been replaced by a specific Agency named Agenzia Nazionale di Valutazione del Sistema Universitario e della Ricerca (ANVUR). This Agency, set up at the end of 2006, aims to «...rationalize the system of assessment of the quality of Universities, state and private Research Institutions beneficiary of public funds...» « The results of these activities managed by ANVUR represent a criteria to assign the state funds to Universities and Research Institutions». It is not hard to imagine that the effects of this type of exercise has a strong political implication and determines a significant economic impact on the future of Universities and Research Institutions. The debate concerning the adopted methods and critical aspects about the assessment exercises is studied thoroughly at international level. At the present time, ANVUR has completed two evaluation exercises of the quality of the research named Valutazione della Qualità della Ricerca (VQR): the first one spans the years 2004 - 2010; the second from 2011 to 2014. The work analyzes the environment of VQR in order to understand the organizational set-up, the operational models, the scientific areas involved in the process, the selection and evaluation criteria and indicators of the research products. The work looks at the environment of VQR in order to understand the organizational set-up, the operational models, the scientific Areas involved in the process and the selection and evaluation criteria of the research products. More in detail, our work analyzes and compares the evaluation exercises conducted in Italy with the aim of verifying if and how Grey Literature is involved in the research evaluation processes. The article checked the types of products admissible for the research assessment and those actually presented by the researchers of Universities and Research Institutions. We measured the products from a quantitative point of view and observed their ramification in the different disciplinary fields rather than their transformation during the period of time taken into consideration. At the same time, we focused on the Open Science movement in order to understand what could be its role within the research assessment exercises and how it could affect the future of scholarly scientific communication.Source: THE GREY JOURNAL, vol. 14 (issue 2), pp. 55-68
Giannini S, Deluca R, Molino A, Biagioni S
In the recent years the application of strategies, procedures and tools to evaluate the research have become subject of interest and their application is currently matter of discussion. The assessment exercises are regulated at national level and are carried out in different European countries such as France, United Kingdom and The Netherlands. In Italy the first research assessment exercise has been legislated in 2003 and entrusted to a specific Committee named Comitato di Indirizzo per la Valutazione della Ricerca (CIVR)1. Three years later the CIVR and other committees have been replaced by a specific Agency named Agenzia Nazionale di Valutazione del Sistema Universitario e della Ricerca (ANVUR). This Agency, set up at the end of 2006, aims to «...rationalize the system of assessment of the quality of Universities, state and private Research Institutions beneficiary of public funds...» « The results of these activities managed by ANVUR represent a criteria to assign the state funds to Universities and Research Institutions». It is not hard to imagine that the effects of this type of exercise has a strong political implication and determines a significant economic impact on the future of Universities and Research Institutions. The debate concerning the adopted methods and critical aspects about the assessment exercises is studied thoroughly at international level. At the present time, ANVUR has completed two evaluation exercises of the quality of the research named Valutazione della Qualità della Ricerca (VQR): the first one spans the years 2004 - 2010; the second from 2011 to 2014. The work analyzes the environment of VQR in order to understand the organizational set-up, the operational models, the scientific areas involved in the process, the selection and evaluation criteria and indicators of the research products. The work looks at the environment of VQR in order to understand the organizational set-up, the operational models, the scientific Areas involved in the process and the selection and evaluation criteria of the research products. More in detail, our work analyzes and compares the evaluation exercises conducted in Italy with the aim of verifying if and how Grey Literature is involved in the research evaluation processes. The article checked the types of products admissible for the research assessment and those actually presented by the researchers of Universities and Research Institutions. We measured the products from a quantitative point of view and observed their ramification in the different disciplinary fields rather than their transformation during the period of time taken into consideration. At the same time, we focused on the Open Science movement in order to understand what could be its role within the research assessment exercises and how it could affect the future of scholarly scientific communication.Source: THE GREY JOURNAL, vol. 14 (issue 2), pp. 55-68
See at:
ISTI Repository | greynet.org | CNR IRIS | CNR IRIS
2018
Conference article
Open Access
Grey Literature and Research Assessment Exercises: from the current criteria to the open science models
Giannini S, Deluca R, Molino A, Biagioni S
In the recent years the application of strategies, procedures and tools to evaluate the research have become subject of interest and their application is currently matter of discussion. The assessment exercises are regulated at national level and are carried out in different European countries such as France, United Kingdom and The Netherlands. In Italy the first research assessment exercise has been legislated in 2003 and entrusted to a specific Committee named Comitato di Indirizzo per la Valutazione della Ricerca (CIVR)1. Three years later the CIVR and other committees have been replaced by a specific Agency named Agenzia Nazionale di Valutazione del Sistema Universitario e della Ricerca (ANVUR). This Agency, set up at the end of 2006, aims to «...rationalize the system of assessment of the quality of Universities, state and private Research Institutions beneficiary of public funds...» « The results of these activities managed by ANVUR represent a criteria to assign the state funds to Universities and Research Institutions». It is not hard to imagine that the effects of this type of exercise has a strong political implication and determines a significant economic impact on the future of Universities and Research Institutions. The debate concerning the adopted methods and critical aspects about the assessment exercises is studied thoroughly at international level. At the present time, ANVUR has completed two evaluation exercises of the quality of the research named Valutazione della Qualità della Ricerca (VQR): the first one spans the years 2004 - 2010; the second from 2011 to 2014. The work analyzes the environment of VQR in order to understand the organizational set-up, the operational models, the scientific areas involved in the process, the selection and evaluation criteria and indicators of the research products. The work looks at the environment of VQR in order to understand the organizational set-up, the operational models, the scientific Areas involved in the process and the selection and evaluation criteria of the research products. More in detail, our work analyzes and compares the evaluation exercises conducted in Italy with the aim of verifying if and how Grey Literature is involved in the research evaluation processes. The article checked the types of products admissible for the research assessment and those actually presented by the researchers of Universities and Research Institutions. We measured the products from a quantitative point of view and observed their ramification in the different disciplinary fields rather than their transformation during the period of time taken into consideration. At the same time, we focused on the Open Science movement in order to understand what could be its role within the research assessment exercises and how it could affect the future of scholarly scientific communication.Source: THE GL-CONFERENCE SERIES. CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS, pp. 11-25. Roma, Italy, 23-24 October 2017
Giannini S, Deluca R, Molino A, Biagioni S
In the recent years the application of strategies, procedures and tools to evaluate the research have become subject of interest and their application is currently matter of discussion. The assessment exercises are regulated at national level and are carried out in different European countries such as France, United Kingdom and The Netherlands. In Italy the first research assessment exercise has been legislated in 2003 and entrusted to a specific Committee named Comitato di Indirizzo per la Valutazione della Ricerca (CIVR)1. Three years later the CIVR and other committees have been replaced by a specific Agency named Agenzia Nazionale di Valutazione del Sistema Universitario e della Ricerca (ANVUR). This Agency, set up at the end of 2006, aims to «...rationalize the system of assessment of the quality of Universities, state and private Research Institutions beneficiary of public funds...» « The results of these activities managed by ANVUR represent a criteria to assign the state funds to Universities and Research Institutions». It is not hard to imagine that the effects of this type of exercise has a strong political implication and determines a significant economic impact on the future of Universities and Research Institutions. The debate concerning the adopted methods and critical aspects about the assessment exercises is studied thoroughly at international level. At the present time, ANVUR has completed two evaluation exercises of the quality of the research named Valutazione della Qualità della Ricerca (VQR): the first one spans the years 2004 - 2010; the second from 2011 to 2014. The work analyzes the environment of VQR in order to understand the organizational set-up, the operational models, the scientific areas involved in the process, the selection and evaluation criteria and indicators of the research products. The work looks at the environment of VQR in order to understand the organizational set-up, the operational models, the scientific Areas involved in the process and the selection and evaluation criteria of the research products. More in detail, our work analyzes and compares the evaluation exercises conducted in Italy with the aim of verifying if and how Grey Literature is involved in the research evaluation processes. The article checked the types of products admissible for the research assessment and those actually presented by the researchers of Universities and Research Institutions. We measured the products from a quantitative point of view and observed their ramification in the different disciplinary fields rather than their transformation during the period of time taken into consideration. At the same time, we focused on the Open Science movement in order to understand what could be its role within the research assessment exercises and how it could affect the future of scholarly scientific communication.Source: THE GL-CONFERENCE SERIES. CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS, pp. 11-25. Roma, Italy, 23-24 October 2017
See at:
CNR IRIS | ISTI Repository | CNR IRIS
2017
Conference article
Open Access
Grey Literature and Research Assessment exercises: from the current criteria to the Open Science models
Giannini S, Deluca R, Molino A, Biagioni S
In the recent years the application of strategies, procedures and tools to evaluate the research have become subject of interest and their application is currently matter of discussion. The assessment exercises are regulated at national level and are carried out in different European countries such as France, United Kingdom and The Netherlands. In Italy the first research assessment exercise has been legislated in 2003 and entrusted to a specific Committee named Comitato di Indirizzo per la Valutazione della Ricerca (CIVR)1. Three years later the CIVR and other committees have been replaced by a specific Agency named Agenzia Nazionale di Valutazione del Sistema Universitario e della Ricerca (ANVUR). This Agency, set up at the end of 2006, aims to «...rationalize the system of assessment of the quality of Universities, state and private Research Institutions beneficiary of public funds...» « The results of these activities managed by ANVUR represent a criteria to assign the state funds to Universities and Research Institutions». It is not hard to imagine that the effects of this type of exercise has a strong political implication and determines a significant economic impact on the future of Universities and Research Institutions. The debate concerning the adopted methods and critical aspects about the assessment exercises is studied thoroughly at international level. At the present time, ANVUR has completed two evaluation exercises of the quality of the research named Valutazione della Qualità della Ricerca (VQR): the first one spans the years 2004 - 2010; the second from 2011 to 2014. The work analyzes the environment of VQR in order to understand the organizational set-up, the operational models, the scientific areas involved in the process, the selection and evaluation criteria and indicators of the research products. The work looks at the environment of VQR in order to understand the organizational set-up, the operational models, the scientific Areas involved in the process and the selection and evaluation criteria of the research products. More in detail, our work analyzes and compares the evaluation exercises conducted in Italy with the aim of verifying if and how Grey Literature is involved in the research evaluation processes. The article checked the types of products admissible for the research assessment and those actually presented by the researchers of Universities and Research Institutions. We measured the products from a quantitative point of view and observed their ramification in the different disciplinary fields rather than their transformation during the period of time taken into consideration. At the same time, we focused on the Open Science movement in order to understand what could be its role within the research assessment exercises and how it could affect the future of scholarly scientific communication.
Giannini S, Deluca R, Molino A, Biagioni S
In the recent years the application of strategies, procedures and tools to evaluate the research have become subject of interest and their application is currently matter of discussion. The assessment exercises are regulated at national level and are carried out in different European countries such as France, United Kingdom and The Netherlands. In Italy the first research assessment exercise has been legislated in 2003 and entrusted to a specific Committee named Comitato di Indirizzo per la Valutazione della Ricerca (CIVR)1. Three years later the CIVR and other committees have been replaced by a specific Agency named Agenzia Nazionale di Valutazione del Sistema Universitario e della Ricerca (ANVUR). This Agency, set up at the end of 2006, aims to «...rationalize the system of assessment of the quality of Universities, state and private Research Institutions beneficiary of public funds...» « The results of these activities managed by ANVUR represent a criteria to assign the state funds to Universities and Research Institutions». It is not hard to imagine that the effects of this type of exercise has a strong political implication and determines a significant economic impact on the future of Universities and Research Institutions. The debate concerning the adopted methods and critical aspects about the assessment exercises is studied thoroughly at international level. At the present time, ANVUR has completed two evaluation exercises of the quality of the research named Valutazione della Qualità della Ricerca (VQR): the first one spans the years 2004 - 2010; the second from 2011 to 2014. The work analyzes the environment of VQR in order to understand the organizational set-up, the operational models, the scientific areas involved in the process, the selection and evaluation criteria and indicators of the research products. The work looks at the environment of VQR in order to understand the organizational set-up, the operational models, the scientific Areas involved in the process and the selection and evaluation criteria of the research products. More in detail, our work analyzes and compares the evaluation exercises conducted in Italy with the aim of verifying if and how Grey Literature is involved in the research evaluation processes. The article checked the types of products admissible for the research assessment and those actually presented by the researchers of Universities and Research Institutions. We measured the products from a quantitative point of view and observed their ramification in the different disciplinary fields rather than their transformation during the period of time taken into consideration. At the same time, we focused on the Open Science movement in order to understand what could be its role within the research assessment exercises and how it could affect the future of scholarly scientific communication.
See at:
greyguide.isti.cnr.it | CNR IRIS | ISTI Repository | CNR IRIS | CNR IRIS